24.07.2007 N -2778/02 III 2007

, , . . . , .

2007
        
                     - 
   
                                 
                      24  2007 . N -2778/02
   
                     
                         III  2007 
   
             -
                 
     -    ()     
       III    2007      
   .
               ""    
                   
       II  2007     
   .
                   
     -  ,    
             
              ,  
                
    .
             - 
                     ,
                  ,
                
                
     .
                  
         .           
     0,94,        1   2005 
       .     
        .
                 
                          
   -      .
                         
     ,       
             
   -         
                            
   -             
     ,   "".
   
                                               
                                                             ..
   
   
   
   
   
                                                            
                                                       
                                        24  2007 . N -2778/02
   
                  ( )
          III  2007     1991  2001 
                       
   
   ----T--------------------T--------T--------T-------------------T--------T-------------------
    N                            
                              +-----T------T------+  +-----T------T------+
                          1991 . -2001-. -2001-.
                            (   (    .   (   . 
                            )    )              .   )              . 
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   I                                :                             
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   1   47,22   4,34    4,01 6,00  3,17  4,12    3,76 5,62  3,75  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   2       45,50   4,83    4,28 7,56  3,71  4,02    3,70 5,49  3,16  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   3   51,40   4,43    3,81 6,82  4,07  4,43    3,79 6,82  4,43  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   4    48,24   5,31    4,67 7,43  4,96  4,66    3,91 7,42  4,65  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   5     44,35   4,25    3,81 6,60  3,23  4,05    3,79 5,32  3,42  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   6      41,31   3,93    3,32 6,19  4,17  3,80    3,23 5,80  4,02  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   7    40,93   4,03    3,41 6,72  3,98  3,98    3,47 5,89  4,00  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   8        47,75   4,45    3,97 6,52  3,46  4,15    3,66 6,00  3,98  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   9       46,28   5,03    3,78 11,81 3,97  4,29    3,48 7,42  3,72  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   10    56,80   4,97    3,82 9,23  4,70  4,98    3,83 9,24  4,75  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   11     43,80   4,20    3,71 6,16  3,57  4,23    3,74 6,23  3,59  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   12   (247,32   4,10    3,58 6,07  4,01  4,20    3,71 6,07  3,98  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   13    43,44   4,80    4,29 7,13  4,03  4,33    3,97 5,79  4,01  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   14    50,67   4,07    3,61 6,16  4,14  3,95    3,67 5,04  3,99  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   15      52,19   4,53    3,92 7,28  3,82  4,86    4,37 7,03  3,68  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   16   (1 42,39   4,55    4,13 6,12  5,19  4,54    4,22 5,72  4,65  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   17   43,58   3,78    3,06 6,61  3,51  3,92    3,21 6,61  3,51  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   18 .  <*>       56,65   -       -    -     0,00  4,94    3,74 9,33  4,70  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   II                           -  :                           
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   19    56,55   4,29    3,85 6,30  3,50  5,37    4,88 7,48  4,52  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   20   (1  43,19   4,15    3,58 6,76  3,79  5,12    4,62 7,24  4,43  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   21        56,45   3,83    2,93 7,72  4,43  5,96    4,85 10,19 5,28  
       (1 )                                                              
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   22   41,01   4,46    4,18 5,92  3,39  4,83    4,54 6,18  3,95  
      (3 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   23      50,38   3,64    3,11 6,53  2,94  4,93    4,52 6,95  3,48  
                                                                             
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   24        50,97   3,57    3,62 3,48  3,99  4,52    4,02 6,60  3,82  
       (1 )                                                              
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   25    55,52   4,32    3,76 5,95  5,47  7,25    6,15 11,64 6,22  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   26  52,25   4,27    4,20 4,52  4,58  5,00    4,51 6,85  4,94  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   27   (150,07   4,92    4,41 7,05  4,62  4,54    4,11 6,03  4,96  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   28 . -  55,71   4,57    0,00 0,00  0,00  5,06    4,29 7,92  4,99  
                          <**>                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   III                                 :                                
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   29     46,11   4,41    3,85 6,70  3,94  4,16    3,65 6,10  3,81  
      ()                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   30   45,32   3,84    3,29 6,60  3,13  4,63    4,20 6,60  3,52  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   31  47,95   4,07    3,60 6,08  3,59  4,00    3,56 5,72  3,72  
      <**>                                                                          
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   32 -43,73   3,83    3,60 4,81  3,43  4,18    3,95 5,44  2,95  
       (1 )                                                           
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   33   52,98   4,23    3,50 8,03  3,97  4,30    3,83 6,23  3,78  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   34 -45,88   4,83    4,47 6,24  4,52  4,25    3,88 5,68  4,23  
                                                                          
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   35   43,04   3,77    3,50 4,74  3,62  4,12    3,77 5,45  4,00  
       -                                                                
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   36  54,27   4,69    3,96 7,04  3,26  5,11    3,93 9,71  3,99  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   37    40,37   4,24    3,46 7,34  3,85  3,99    3,28 6,68  3,71  
      <*>                                                                           
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   38   38,46   4,62    3,79 7,93  5,24  4,11    3,49 6,20  4,63  
                                                     <**>                     <**>  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   39  41,13   3,78    3,28 6,36  3,08  4,27    3,91 5,84  3,52  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   40        47,13   4,35    3,80 6,40  4,42  4,26    3,71 6,31  4,10  
                                                                             
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   41    40,38   4,58    4,31 5,79  3,92  4,51    4,23 5,79  3,85  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   IV                               :                             
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   42           37,03   3,71    3,42 4,90  3,05  4,21    3,70 6,19  3,80  
                                                                        
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   43    39,43   3,84    3,11 7,49  3,20  4,03    3,46 6,33  3,39  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   44   40,32   4,30    3,95 6,75  2,02  4,35    3,90 6,32  3,39  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   45  40,47   3,96    3,19 7,37  2,85  4,02    3,28 6,90  3,49  
      ()                                                                   
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   46           45,48   4,36    3,91 6,27  3,58  4,63    4,16 6,73  3,51  
                                                                          
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   47  40,91   4,35    3,67 7,00  4,20  4,27    3,64 6,53  4,46  
      -            <**>               <**>  <**>               <**>  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   48   (151,74   4,48    4,07 5,98  3,97  4,72    4,21 6,82  4,15  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   49        43,81   4,35    3,69 6,70  4,16  4,41    3,66 7,02  4,78  
                                                                             
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   50 .             48,26   4,33    4,11 5,31  3,68  4,60    4,22 6,28  3,77  
      (                                                                
      )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   51  -       3,53    3,25 4,77  3,24  3,93    3,68 4,96  3,78  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   52    38,75   3,61    3,15 5,86  3,07  4,12    3,77 5,70  3,30  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   53      33,70   3,35    3,07 4,39  2,65  3,95    3,41 6,25  3,07  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   54     43,30   4,22    4,10 4,85  3,49  4,24    3,66 6,30  4,42  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   55   42,19   4,03    3,66 5,62  3,33  4,00    3,57 5,63  4,03  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   56   44,00   4,04    3,80 5,29  3,07  3,96    3,62 5,29  3,74  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   V                                 :                              
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   57    41,20   3,48    3,06 5,33  3,26  3,94    3,53 5,33  4,51  
      <*>                                                                           
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   58  34,78   3,75    3,41 5,00  2,76  4,27    3,58 7,05  3,43  
      (. )                                                             
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   59   (155,16   4,27    3,38 7,59  3,60  4,53    3,55 8,30  3,80  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   60   43,29   3,97    3,90 4,47  3,20  4,25    3,93 5,65  3,61  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   61 -    41,26   2,93    2,54 3,89  2,68  6,16    4,56 12,22 5,21  
                                                                     
      ()                                                                        
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   62 -      45,21   3,69    3,61 4,18  2,99  5,25    4,97 6,94  3,20  
        (2         <**>    <**> <**>        <**>    <**> <**>        
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   VI                                :                              
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   63   (1 46,17   4,40    3,79 7,09  3,24  5,25    4,61 8,26  3,07  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   64    48,72   4,04    3,64 5,28  4,18  4,83    4,14 7,38  4,81  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   65       41,61   3,75    3,72 4,01  3,26  4,96    4,64 6,40  4,26  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   66    45,31   3,68    3,17 5,70  3,65  4,95    4,34 7,43  4,23  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   67   (1   45,72   4,34    3,69 7,58  3,00  4,76    4,24 7,25  2,91  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   68   (148,84   3,16    2,86 4,10  2,90  4,70    3,97 7,53  4,13  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   69     51,34   4,15    3,51 6,38  5,18  5,42    4,71 7,95  5,91  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   70   49,51   3,54    3,08 5,57  2,98  4,54    3,99 6,69  4,21  
      (2 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   71        39,48   4,25    3,86 5,90  3,71  5,04    4,62 6,97  3,98  
       (4 )                                                              
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   72        48,13   3,64    2,79 9,00  3,63  4,56    3,93 7,11  3,81  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   73       57,39   4,43    4,05 5,75  4,12  5,34    4,64 8,10  4,69  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   74   (148,73   4,11    3,34 7,84  3,79  4,63    4,01 7,04  4,21  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   VII                            :                           
   +---+--------------------T--------T--------T-----T------T------T--------T-----T------T------+
   75       39,10   3,63    3,56 4,06  2,50  7,35    6,22 12,34 4,49  
      (),                                                               
      +--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
            40,70   3,29    3,66 2,76  2,32  9,29    8,88 12,34 4,68  
      (),                                                               
      +--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
            38,12   3,60    3,52 4,06  2,43  7,10    5,90 12,34 4,29  
      (),                                                             
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   76       49,29   4,91    3,92 8,86  2,97  5,69    4,50 10,75 3,07  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   77   (1 42,83   3,89    3,19 7,03  2,43  5,43    4,57 9,32  3,00  
      )                                                                         
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   78      46,52   4,07    3,35 7,18  3,03  4,85    4,09 8,08  3,44  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   79    54,42   3,34    2,80 5,42  2,90  8,86    7,43 14,89 6,12  
      (1 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   80   43,95   3,58    3,22 5,26  3,01  8,55    8,09 11,43 4,98  
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   81   52,78   3,63    3,96 3,20  3,19  9,85    8,77 15,23 5,25  
      (2 )                                                                      
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   82  -       3,35    2,86 5,59  2,94  4,95    4,43 7,30  3,62  
                                                                             
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   83  -       2,48    2,14 4,51  2,69  9,89    9,60 12,35 5,68  
       <*>                                                                     
   +---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+------+
   84  43,57   2,83    2,20 6,82  4,05  11,57   10,3217,59 6,97  
       <*>                                                                     
   L---+--------------------+--------+--------+-----+------+------+--------+-----+------+-------
   
   --------------------------------
       <*>   ,   "".
       <**>    .
   
       :
       1.            
         :
       -      - 1,02 (   ), 1,005
   (   );
       -    ,       , -
   1,01 (   ), 1,003 (   ).
                     1991
       .
       2.           
                 (  
               )      ,
         .      
     .
       3.          -  
        .
    

2007
        
                          
                                   
                          
                  
                                   
                                
                       8  2005 . N 1485
                                   
             
                    ""
   
             8  2001 . N 128-
     "    ", 
        17  2004  .  N  294  "
           "
            ""            
                    
   :
       1.        (N  001491-)     
           (  )
       5    ""  1022402665890 ( 2466000169),
     : , 660020,    ,
   . , . 3- , . 1.
       2.         
                  
                    ""
      .
       3.            
       .. .
   
                                                          
                                                 
                                                            ..
   
   
   
   
   
                                                            
                                                  
                                               
                                              
                                             8  2005 . N 1485
   
                               ""
   
         :  ,  660020,    ,   .
   , . 3- , . 1.
   
                      :
                         
   
   -----T-----------------T--------------T--------------------------
    N                         
   /                         
   +----+-----------------+--------------+--------------------------+
   1            0...360-   , ,     
                         +/- 60-                   
   +----+-----------------+--------------+--------------------------+
   2            2...200      , ,     
                                                     
   +----+-----------------+--------------+--------------------------+
   3          0,2...5000    .      
                         0...360-           -6                
                         +/- 60-    2 +/- 10               
                                       . : 0,5"...30" 
                                      : 1"...45"              
   +----+-----------------+--------------+--------------------------+
   4     0,001...20   .      
                                              -6                
                                      2 +/- 10               
   +----+-----------------+--------------+--------------------------+
   5              . : +/- 30"    
                        350              
                        : +/- 45-   20                      
   L----+-----------------+--------------+---------------------------
   
                                                          
                                                 ,
                                               
                                                 
                                           
                                                           
                                                          ..